Rhonda's Blog                    
Mainpage Disclaimer

Tue, 16 Sep 2008

webwml in git

Last week I wondered how much space a complete git conversion would actually need—and I was quite surprised:

$ du -hs webwml*
325M    webwml
416M    webwml.git
819M    webwml.svn

The first line is the regular CVS checkout. The third line is the SVN checkout that's available from alioth. You can see that the size is not really something one would want, especially since the real gain is extremely little: besides offline diff you rather have disadvantages with not being able to do much offline because anything history wise requires you to be online. In CVS you at least knew that revision 1.12 of a file is three commits above revision 1.9 of the same file; while in SVN you have no chance offline to know how many commits to a file happened between revision 512 and 1024, if any at all.

The conversion to git took me quite a long time, practically almost three days of (non-constant) running git-cvsimport on my laptop. The time did not completely surprise me, at least when I noticed in the end that it were well over 83 thousand commits in well over 10 years, reaching back to July 1998. My first own commit was in July 2001, which wasn't too hard to find out with git neither, and required no online operation.

git gives you complete offline access to the history. This is actually something that the build process can be based on. There propably will be some speed drawback with not being able to do simple-math for revision difference like in CVS, but that actually will have to be checked. I'm still convinced being able to do all the stuff offline without any strange hacks or needing to be online all the time is something worthwhile.

Things left to do and which I propably won't find the time in the too near future because of ... erm, you know? Lenny? That we want to release? But anyway, to not have the list of things get lost, here is a (not complete) list of things in case you are bored and want to play around a bit:

  • Adapt the various scripts to not check CVS revisions but use the sha1 sums.
  • Adjust translation-check translation="" value for all files to use sha1 sums.
  • Check wether a full website build would work after that changes.
  • Try out how submodules work and wether they might be reasonable to use for language subdirectories to allow translators partial checkouts.
  • ... other things I've forgotten but that could be added to the WebsiteVCSEvalutaion wiki page.

Playing around a bit? Well, you don't have to do the whole git-cvsimport on yourself: I've pushed my webwml.git repository to alioth: "git clone git://git.debian.org/git/users/alfie/webwml.git" should get you started. Please notice to play around in a seperate branch and not directly in origin to be able to pull further and update from time to time.

/debian | permanent link | Comments: 0

Trackbacks are closed for this story.

Comments are closed for this story.

If you want to syndicate this blog, feel free to do so.
This list contains the feeds that I follow:

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30  


©opyright 1999++ by Rhonda
[rss feed]

[html by vim] [graphics by gimp]

[generated by wml]

[powered by blosxom]